.webp)
.webp)
.webp){kind=icon}
11 Best Bakeries for Custom Cakes and Fall Treats in 2025
Fall is the season of cozy flavors and gatherings, which makes bakeries busier than ever. From pumpkin-glazed donuts to caramel apple cakes, these bakeries are rolling out creative seasonal menus while also offering quick mobile ordering and loyalty perks that keep regulars coming back. Custom cakes and cookies for birthdays, weddings, and themed parties are also at the heart of many of these shops, giving customers something personal while still tasting homemade.
This guide highlights eleven local bakeries across the US that stand out not only for their fall flavors but also for their ability to make custom treats easy to order. Whether it’s a pumpkin spice latte cupcake, a tailored wedding cake, or a simple box of cookies for an office party, these bakeries deliver on flavor, creativity, and convenience.
list
BAM Desserts
BAM Desserts has built a reputation for custom cookies and cupcakes that not only look stunning but actually taste homemade. They are a go-to choice for themed parties and weddings, especially since they specialize in eggless, vegan, and gluten-conscious options. A monthly new flavor drop keeps the menu fresh, and mini desserts round out the case. Mobile ordering is seamless through their rewards app, which adds a layer of convenience that big chains can’t compete with.
Blue Umbrella Bakery
Blue Umbrella Bakery in downtown Keokuk is equal parts cozy café and custom cake destination. The menu mixes scratch-made bagels, scones, and cakes with highly personalized cupcake arrangements that often exceed expectations. Cupcake bouquets, layered cakes, and tailored seasonal orders are just a few of the highlights. For fall, seasonal cakes with fruit fillings and spiced frostings shine, while the bakery’s approachable ordering system makes it easy to grab treats on the go.
.svg)
.webp)
4.2
of 5.0
(19)
Miz Kathi’s Café & Sweetery
Miz Kathi’s blends a Southern café atmosphere with a sweetery full of seasonal indulgences. The fall lineup includes a Brown Sugar Pumpkin cake layered with honey pie-spiced buttercream and caramel. Tailored treat boxes are a favorite for gifting, while the café menu itself offers homestyle meals that complement the baked goods. Mobile ordering makes picking up custom cakes or seasonal slices simple, and the bakery’s warm hospitality is part of what keeps regulars coming back.
Cake Krums Cafe
Cake Krums Café is known for wedding cakes that nail both design and flavor. The team works closely with customers to bring visions to life, often pulling inspiration from event themes. Seasonal cakes like red velvet and sangria tiers stand out, while the café side offers everyday pastries and coffee in a welcoming space. Curbside pickup and mobile app ordering make it easy to grab last-minute treats or coffee runs. Baking classes around the holidays add another layer of charm, making this bakery a community favorite.
Double Batch Bakery
Double Batch Bakery in Bayonne is the definition of modern convenience with a window service concept and app-based ordering that makes grabbing sweets effortless. Custom cakes and cupcakes are popular, but their $10 surprise pastry box keeps fans guessing and returning. Seasonal offerings lean into cozy comfort, making their fall lineup especially popular. Quick pickup and mobile-friendly service set Double Batch apart from more traditional bakeries.
4.4
of 5.0
(349)
Pekara Bakery & Bistro
Pekara Bakery & Bistro brings European-inspired baking to life with both custom orders and seasonal menus. Their fall features include Caramel Apple French Toast, pumpkin crepes, and Caramel Apple Cider, made with local orchard produce. Custom macaron towers are highlights for weddings and events, and the loyalty app rewards regular visits. The espresso bar balances out the sweet options, making Pekara as much a place for morning coffee as it is for elaborate celebration orders.
Whisk & Arrow Sugar Studio
Whisk & Arrow offers a French bakery experience with a modern twist. The menu rotates with specials, but the star of the season is their fall-inspired pastries. Their mobile app allows advance ordering and rewards, perfect for those who want to skip the line and still snag a bag of cookies or macarons. Custom cakes and seasonal items are designed with both aesthetics and flavor in mind, making this spot as appealing for celebrations as it is for everyday indulgence.
4.3
of 5.0
(508)
Country Donuts - NY
Country Donuts is a family-owned shop that blends the traditional donut shop experience with seasonal creativity. Their pumpkin-glazed donut with pumpkin cream filling and a crumble topping has become a fall must-try. Beyond donuts, the shop offers smoothies, bagels, cookies, and coffee, making it more than just a quick breakfast stop. Everything is baked fresh daily, and the loyal following it has built proves that consistency and seasonal surprises keep people coming back.
Baking Up a Storm
Baking Up a Storm thrives on variety, with a case full of cupcakes, breads, and seasonal pastries. Their fall menu brings cozy flavors into play with themed cupcakes and pastries available for mobile ordering. The bakery also caters to dietary needs, ensuring inclusivity alongside creativity. From rhubarb bread to German chocolate cupcakes, every order feels thoughtfully made and worth savoring.
Sweet Corner Cakes
Sweet Corner Cakes has earned loyal fans for its custom cakes that balance design with taste. Birthday cakes, wedding cakes, and cupcake packs are a specialty, but their fall menu expands into seasonal flavors and quick-order cupcakes. Loyalty rewards and app-based ordering make it simple to plan for events or drop in for Thursday cupcake specials. The shop atmosphere adds to the charm, but the real draw is the ability to count on consistent flavor and flawless presentation.
Kenzie’s Kakes & Coffee
Kenzie’s Kakes & Coffee combines bakery charm with a café vibe, offering custom cakes alongside creative monthly themes. Recent custom orders have included superhero birthday cakes and seasonal cupcake collections. Coffee drinks pair well with the desserts, especially seasonal specialties like chocolate-covered strawberry lattes. Ordering through their app makes custom requests easy, and the loyalty perks add value for regulars.
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
.webp)