.webp)
.webp)
.webp){kind=icon}
Where to Get the Best Cookies in America That Aren’t Crumbl
America’s obsession with cookies runs deep. Whether it’s the late-night craving for something sweet, the comfort of a warm chocolate chip cookie, or just the joy of trying a new bakery on a road trip, cookies have become a national love language. While Crumbl might be leading the charge in the cookie chain world, there are so many other small bakeries across the country doing it better, with more personality, flavor, and that made-with-love energy. We’ve been tasting our way through local favorites and hidden gems, and this guide is for anyone who wants a cookie that delivers more than just size and frosting. These are real-deal cookie spots that actually live up to the hype and then some.
list
.svg)
.webp)
4.6
of 5.0
(143)
Michael's Cookie Jar – Houston
The Dubai Chocolate Cookie is a game changer, but the Ballpark Cookie with Reese's pieces and caramel popcorn gives it a run for its money. Each cookie is rich, flavorful, and generously portioned. It’s the kind of spot that turns casual visits into traditions. The friendly staff and playful seasonal treats keep regulars coming back.
Chip City Cookies- Chicago
These cookies are dangerously good, soft, warm, and gooey in the center. Try the s’mores, red velvet, or cookies and cream while they’re hot from the oven. Their rotating menu and easy-to-use app make every visit exciting. The friendly service seals the deal.
Crave Cookies - Lake View East
Crave lives up to its name with inventive flavors and generous hospitality. Staff members make you feel like family, often tossing in a free cookie or a recommendation. Nut allergy-friendly and always fresh, their cookies are chewy, thick, and perfectly balanced. A must for any cookie lover.
D's Dough - New Jersey
D's Dough delivers warm, decadent cookies with a gooey inside and light crunch on the outside. Holiday flavors and classic chocolate chip alike are baked to perfection. The shop is clean, the staff is upbeat, and each cookie is packed with flavor. One bite and you’ll understand the hype.
4.8
of 5.0
(27)
Kookaburra Cookies - Omaha
These thick, hearty cookies are a farmers market favorite in Omaha and Lincoln. The texture and flavor are always on point, and owner Eli brings unbeatable energy to every pop-up. Order online or catch them around town. Either way, it’s worth it.
Doug and Dolly's Cookies – Nashville
From French silk to peanut butter Reese’s, these cookies are all about cozy, nostalgic flavor. Each bite is indulgent and perfectly balanced. The friendly service and pretty storefront make it a sweet stop every time. Great for gifts or a personal treat.
Sloth Cookies – Utah
Sloth Cookies knows how to do simple right with warm, melt-in-your-mouth classics. The chocolate chip and namesake Sloth Cookie are crowd favorites. The new location is cozy and easy to find, and the value for portion size is hard to beat.
RubySnap Fresh Cookies – Salt Lake City
RubySnap nails flavor and creativity with cookies like the raspberry cream cheese dream. You’ll get samples, smiles, and possibly a new addiction. Their gluten-free options are just as tasty as the regular lineup. This is not your average cookie stop.
HiFi Cookies - East Nashville
HiFi mixes music and dessert in the best way, offering monthly flavors inspired by pop culture. Collaborations with chefs keep the menu fresh and unexpected. Whether it’s their rice crispy treat or seasonal cookie box, everything here feels thoughtfully crafted. A great local gift idea, too.
Pink Door Cookies – Nashville
This colorful neighborhood spot serves up seven-layer cookies, vegan oatmeal raisin, and plenty of charm. It’s as much about the vibe as the treats. Staff are welcoming and quick to offer suggestions. Bonus points for dog treats and outdoor seating.
4.8
of 5.0
(106)
The Cookie Crate – Elizabethton
Cookie Crate is known for excellent shipping and presentation, making it a favorite for gifting. Their seasonal boxes are popular for holidays and special occasions. Flavors range from classic to creative, and everything arrives soft and fresh. The customer service is stellar.
Whipped Up Cookie Co - Lakewood
Whipped Up delivers stunning cookies for events that taste as good as they look. Samantha’s custom designs are detailed and delicious, earning rave reviews from clients. From baby showers to weddings, these cookies are always the hit of the party. And they ship, too.
W Walnut Cookie Co. – Troy
A charming little spot with fresh-baked cookies and creamy milkshakes, W Walnut is full of flavor and warmth. Their OG chocolate chip is gooey perfection, especially paired with a latte. Locals love the friendly service and cozy space. It's perfect for an afternoon treat.
4.5
of 5.0
(85)
Bendy's Cookies & Cream - Trussville
Snickerdoodle fans, take note: Bendy’s does it right. Their seasonal blackberry buttered biscuit ice cream is also worth a trip. The space is small but cheerful, and the service is quick even for large groups. It’s a hidden gem with loyal regulars.
4.9
of 5.0
(51)
Eileen’s Colossal Cookies – Casper
Affordable, massive cookies with classic flavors and custom options make this a local go-to. Their double lemon and white chocolate cranberry are especially popular. Great for last-minute party orders or a quick sugar fix. Friendly staff and fast turnaround.
4.7
of 5.0
(211)
Kassi’s Cookies (Downtown Conway)
Kassi’s blends small-town charm with big-time flavor. The shop smells like heaven, and the cookies are always warm and soft. Chocolate chip is a standout, but the strawberry is a fun twist. Watch the bakers in action while you snack.
4.8
of 5.0
(441)
Caramel Cookie Waffles Co. – Billings
Famous for their caramel cookie waffles, this café also serves hearty salads and deep-dish pie. It’s a warm, bustling place where you can grab lunch and finish with something sweet. Everything is homemade, and the service is always kind.
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
.webp)