Cap's Montauk Harbor

Image source
Barney Simon

Cap's feels like a fresh addition to Montauk dining, with a seafood menu that impresses from the start. The shellfish pasta is packed with flavor, perfectly seasoned, and cooked to perfection. Lobster rolls here are plump, buttery, and generously filled. The harbor-side setting adds to the charm, giving diners a peaceful view to pair with their meal. Service is lively and friendly, making the whole place feel welcoming. Staff go above and beyond to create a relaxed, happy dining experience. The menu is focused but full of crowd-pleasing choices that showcase local seafood. Prices are fair considering the quality and size of the portions. The atmosphere works equally well for a casual bite or a celebratory dinner. A new favorite for anyone craving fresh seafood by the water.