Image source

San Marzano Trattoria

San Marzano Trattoria blends classic Italian cooking with a relaxed neighborhood vibe. Wood-fired pizzas share the menu with handmade pastas and comforting plates like chicken parm. The Margherita pizza is a favorite, with just the right amount of char on the crust and balance in the toppings. The welcoming space, paired with attentive service, makes it a strong choice for both casual meals and celebratory nights.

Image source
Barney Simon

Cap's Montauk Harbor

Located right on the harbor with fresh shellfish pasta and tame luxe energy. The lobster roll earns praise as “the best locals have ever had” by repeat diners. Service lands with friendly professionalism, and harbor-side views turn lunch into mini vacation mode.