.webp)
.webp)
.webp){kind=icon}
8 Restaurants in Montauk Serving the Best Lobster Rolls This Summer
Summer in Montauk isn’t complete without a lobster roll in hand. This seaside town turns lobster into art, serving both hot buttery New England style and chilled Maine-style classics with mayo and celery. Whether the roll comes with crispy fries, ice-cold ale, or waterfront views, these 8 local favorites define summer flavor. Each spot brings a specific vibe, from roadside shacks to chic harborside decks, with quality ingredients and plenty of atmosphere. This guide highlights the freshest picks for summer 2025, offering fresh takes on what makes a lobster roll iconic in Montauk.
list
Seaside House Bar
The lobster roll here has earned respect from locals and visitors alike. Fresh lobster meat tucked into grilled buns with top-tier service and bar seating that feels breezy and relaxed. A move‑fast patio vibe makes it perfect for days when heat calls for crisp seafood and chilly drinks.
%20s.webp)
.svg)
.webp)
4.5
of 5.0
(1,470)
LUNCH Lobster Roll Amagansett
Legendary original lobster roll spot along Route 27, serving both hot buttered and cold mayo‑dressed rolls. Fries and creamy chowder served in coffee mugs add just the right level of charm. The hot version especially shines, and window-service drinks keep summer waits bearable under the sun.
Hooked - Montauk
Known for a lobster roll described by a Redditor as “the best one is at Hooked in Montauk”. Crispy-on-the-outside buns and generous chunks of lobster meet fast friendly service and shaded outdoor seating. Perfect for days when beach time meets quick bites and solid portions.
4.0
of 5.0
(208)
Sel Rrose Montauk
Chic and inviting, Sel Rrose brings a rooftop or outdoor seating vibe with oysters, shrimp tacos, and an elevated lobster roll. A popular spot for pairing lobster salad rolls with orange wine and seaside ambiance. The lobster roll stands out amid elevated seafood plates and friendly table service.
Shark Bar Montauk
Small menu, big flavor. Lobster roll here feels thoughtfully crafted in a laid-back setting with frozen drinks that feel essential for hot afternoons. Lobster tastes sweet and clean, service is top notch, and outdoor seating draws locals back again and again.
4.3
of 5.0
(12)
Cap's Montauk Harbor
Located right on the harbor with fresh shellfish pasta and tame luxe energy. The lobster roll earns praise as “the best locals have ever had” by repeat diners. Service lands with friendly professionalism, and harbor-side views turn lunch into mini vacation mode.
4.1
of 5.0
(838)
Shagwong
A Montauk institution for decades. The lobster roll here is described as “among the best ever”. Casual sports‑bar style meets seafood classics, zucchini fries, clam chowder, burgers, and the kind of friendly service and relaxed vibe that keeps Montauk regulars coming back season after season.
4.3
of 5.0
(690)
The Point Bar & Grill
Wood-finished interiors open onto alfresco seating and Harbor Water views. Lobster roll shares menu space with mussels, seafood pasta, and buff cauliflower bites. Friendly bartenders pour Bloody Marys and cocktails that feel made for slow summer afternoons by the water.
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
All Rights Reserved © Per Diem Subscription
.webp)