Image source
Andrew Mastorakis

Paulie Gee's

Paulie Gee’s has become a legend for both traditional and inventive pies. The Hellboy slice, topped with pepperoni and a drizzle of spicy honey, has gained cult status, but classics like the vodka slice or square pies also stand tall. The crust is crisp yet airy, with a flavor only a wood-fired oven can deliver. The space captures old-school pizzeria vibes, making it as much about atmosphere as it is about flavor.

Image source

Wahizza Pizzeria ( Dominican- Italian ) Restaurant

Wahizza mixes creativity with tradition, offering pies topped with ingredients like juicy chicken, fresh corn, or bold chimichurri. Their Chimi Pizza has become a house favorite, while Margherita lovers can count on a perfectly balanced classic. Karaoke nights and a full bar make this more than just a pizza joint — it’s also a lively hangout. The combination of wood-fired technique and playful energy ensures each visit feels fresh and memorable.

Image source

Dough & Co. Pizza

Dough & Co. stands out with pies that look as good as they taste, crafted with high-quality toppings and attention to detail. The burrata slice is creamy perfection, while options like the San Genaro pile on sausage and peppers for heartier cravings. The space is clean, welcoming, and family-friendly, with staff who make every visit feel personal. With gelato to finish, this spot is a full experience from start to finish.

Image source

Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza

Toss & Fire built its reputation through food trucks and catering before opening a permanent home. Known for its soft, chewy crusts and bold topping combinations, this pizzeria has a loyal following. Gluten-free options are also done well, earning praise even from those usually skeptical. Beyond the pizza, the large beer selection and friendly staff make it an easy place to settle in for a night out.

Image source

Ops (Bushwick)

Ops in Bushwick puts sourdough at the center of its wood-fired pies, giving each crust a distinct tang and chew. Pizzas like the Juno are layered with thoughtful toppings that complement rather than overwhelm. The cozy, intimate setting makes it an ideal place to linger over wine and share plates. Known for consistency and character, Ops is a spot where both locals and visitors come for a slice of something special.

Image source

San Marzano Trattoria

San Marzano Trattoria blends classic Italian cooking with a relaxed neighborhood vibe. Wood-fired pizzas share the menu with handmade pastas and comforting plates like chicken parm. The Margherita pizza is a favorite, with just the right amount of char on the crust and balance in the toppings. The welcoming space, paired with attentive service, makes it a strong choice for both casual meals and celebratory nights.

Image source

Pizzeria La Rosa

Pizzeria La Rosa shows off the art of simplicity with blistered thin-crust pies that keep toppings fresh and minimal. The Margherita and roasted garlic options are standout examples of how balance makes the best pizza shine. Watching the owner work the oven adds to the charm, while a small library of pizza books sets the tone for how seriously the craft is taken. It’s an understated but unforgettable stop.

Image source

Brooklyn DOP

Brooklyn DOP is the definition of a neighborhood pizzeria that takes quality seriously. The cheese pizza here is a study in balance, with perfectly tangy tomato sauce and a crust that snaps just enough before turning chewy. The pepperoni pies are crowd-pleasers, and the patio seating adds comfort for those who want to linger. It’s a place that proves a slice doesn’t need gimmicks to be memorable.

Image source

SIMÒ PIZZA - MEATPACKING

Simò Pizza delivers Neapolitan-style pizza at affordable prices without cutting corners on quality. The Margherita is a highlight, with thin, slightly charred dough that folds just right. The founder, Simò, brings his roots from Naples into every detail, from the recipes to the warm service. Quick, casual, and delicious, this spot has quickly become a favorite for those chasing authentic Neapolitan flavors in New York.

Image source

Alessio's Cafe

Alessio's Cafe is a neighborhood gem, blending classic café offerings with high-quality pizza and gelato. Under new management, this spot has become a local favorite with friendly service and an inviting ambiance. The combination of coffee, Italian-inspired bites, and welcoming staff makes Alessio’s a unique stop in Hoboken.